Chiefs

A Kansas City Chiefs vs. Indianapolis Colts prediction: Time to overreact, or not?

Details

Kickoff: Noon Central time Sunday

Where: Lucas Oil Stadium, Indianapolis

TV: CBS (Ch. 5) in Kansas City

Radio: WDAF (106.5 FM) in Kansas City

Line: Chiefs by 5.5

Jesse Newell’s prediction

I’m typically the person who will caution everyone not to overreact to the previous week’s results.

Still ... I have to admit it’s hard not to do that with Indianapolis this week following an embarrassing 24-0 road loss to Jacksonville.

According to Football Outsiders’ measures, the Colts — against the Jaguars — had their worst single-game offensive performance since 1992. Quarterback Matt Ryan had arm-strength issues and was uncomfortable in the pocket with pressure from any direction.

Jonathan Taylor had just nine carries, and the offensive line played a part in surrendering five sacks while not opening up enough holes in the run game.

Defensively, Indianapolis was over-aggressive at times and hasn’t been as advertised with its pass rush or in coverage through two games. And while the run defense has been mostly sound, that’s more of a luxury than a necessity against the Chiefs, who tend to throw more than an average team no matter the circumstances.

The Chiefs have some problems of their own. PFF jokes aside, quarterback Patrick Mahomes had a few passes that the Chargers should’ve intercepted a week ago. And for a game, the Chiefs new additions at receiver seemed to have some chemistry issues with Mahomes while failing too often to beat single coverage.

Indianapolis hasn’t had a chance to play at home yet, so the Colts should get a nice boost at Lucas Oil Stadium. Chiefs coach Andy Reid is just 2-3 against Indianapolis while in KC, and last week’s score — as awful as it was for the Colts — doesn’t carry over to this week.

No. 1 Colts receiver Michael Pittman’s expected return from a quad injury can’t be understated either.

After two weeks of picking opposing teams to cover the spread against the Chiefs, though, I’m not feeling that here. Reid and his coaches had a few extra days to scout Indianapolis’ weaknesses; as we saw in the opening blowout against Arizona, that extra time typically results in the Chiefs dissecting the opponent’s tendencies and then exploiting them.

I see the Chiefs’ pass offense having much more success this week and defensive pressure causing the 37-year-old Ryan all sorts of issues as he battles Father Time.

Give me KC for both the win and cover.

Chiefs 30, Colts 21

Jesse’s pick to cover spread: Kansas City

Last game prediction: Chiefs 31, Chargers 28 (Actual: Chiefs 27-24) ✔️

This year’s record vs. spread: 1-1

Jesse Newell
The Kansas City Star
Jesse Newell covered the Chiefs for The Star until August 2025. He won an EPPY for best sports blog and previously was named top beat writer in his circulation by AP’s Sports Editors. His interest in sports analytics comes from his math teacher father, who handed out rulers to Trick-or-Treaters each year.
Sports Pass is your ticket to Kansas City sports
#ReadLocal

Get in-depth, sideline coverage of Kansas City area sports - only $1 a month

VIEW OFFER