Openings & Closings

Old-fashioned ice cream shop is hitting the KC market with Johnson County location

Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream offers dozens of flavors. It’s soon coming to the Kansas City area.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream offers dozens of flavors. It’s soon coming to the Kansas City area. Handel's Homemade

Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream — a chain that makes its frozen treats fresh in-store “like the old days” — is opening its first Kansas City area location.

The company has plans to open a spot at 11885 W. 95th St., near Oak Park Mall. The space was formerly rolled ice cream shop Freezing Moo, and it neighbors Bibibop Asian Grill and Cava.

A spokesperson with Handel’s confirmed to The Star that it would open at the Overland Park location but could not give an exact date. It expects to open sometime this year.

Alice Handel opened a neighborhood ice cream shop called Handel’s in Youngstown, Ohio, in 1945, using her own recipes and fruit from her garden.

Handel’s holds to its original recipes and methods today, though it’s grown to dozens of locations across the country, in Indiana, Colorado, Texas, California, Arkansas and beyond.

The Johnson County spot will be the first Handel’s in Kansas.

Handel’s began in Ohio in 1945. Now it has dozens of locations in the country.
Handel’s began in Ohio in 1945. Now it has dozens of locations in the country. Handel's Homemade

Each store has 48 flavors that rotate monthly. A few on Handel’s menu: bananas foster, caramel pretzel crunch, mocha almond fudge ripple, coconut cream pie and taro.

Handel’s also sells sorbets, sherbets and frozen ice.

This story was originally published March 5, 2025 at 12:01 PM.

Jenna Thompson
The Kansas City Star
Jenna Thompson covers retail news for The Kansas City Star. A native of Lincoln, Nebraska, she previously reported for the Lincoln Journal Star and graduated from the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, where she studied journalism and English.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER