Ball Star

Blogging on the Royals and baseball

All-Star watch: Ranking the Royals

06/04/2012 10:54 AM

05/16/2014 6:37 PM

Five Royals are having All-Star worthy campaigns. There could be some hemming or hawing that Aaron Crow or perhaps Jose Mijares belong on the list too, but it has to be cut off somewhere. Besides, the third-best reliever on a team in a given year has no chance to make an All-Star roster. As much as I would like to make a case for Mitch Maier as a pitcher, this seems like a more realistic look at who might represent the Royals when the spotlight hits Kansas City on July 10.

1. DH Billy Butler Key stats

: .289/.352/.521, 11 2B, 11 HR, 35 RBI

Competition

: David Ortiz, Edwin Encarnacion, Adam Dunn, Michael Young

Odds

: 2/1

The last three seasons, Butler – excuse me, Big Bill (though personally I’ve always preferred to call him “Billy Bats”) – has batted .303/.370/.474 and averaged 18 home runs, 47 doubles, 76 runs scored and 89 RBIs. Still, as Sam Mellinger pointed out in a recent column (http://tinyurl.com/7vp7oea), Butler doesn’t seem to get the credit he deserves.

That’s not just in Kansas City, though. He’s not often mentioned among the best young hitters in the game, but there’s no question the kid – he’s still only 26 – can absolutely rake. Perhaps this is the season Butler finally gets to showcase his immense talent in the Midsummer Classic. It should be.

2. RHP Jonathan Broxton Key stats

: 0-1, 1.83 ERA, 11/13 SV

Competition

: Jim Johnson, Fernando Rodney, Chris Perez, Joe Nathan

Odds

: 6/1

Forget about the back-to-back hit batters against Oakland in the finale of a season-opening road trip. Now, I realize that can be hard for some fans, but Broxton has been solid most of the season. He’s been an adventure at times, with Wednesday afternoon in Cleveland being a prime example, but it’s not quite The Heath Bell Experience.

3. LHP Tim Collins Key stats

: 2-0, 2.42 ERA, 38/7 K/BB, 0.96 WHIP

Competition

: Can anyone really compete with Collins right now

Odds

: 7/1

Collins hasn’t allowed a run in 22 of 24 appearances this season, so his ERA is skewed by a four-run outing April 14 against Cleveland during that disastrous opening homestand and a three-run outing May 7 against Boston. Bottom line is that Collins has been fantastic and provides a reliable left-hander with strikeout stuff to a bullpen that could determine which league secures home-field advantage for the World Series. He’d be a great option for Ron Washington if he’s playing for strategy.

If the Royals get two players, it will be because Washington zeroes in on Collins as a specialist with value from the host team.

4. SS Alcides Escobar Key stats

: .303/.344/.404, 13 2B, 21 R, 8 SB

Competition

: Derek Jeter, Mike Aviles, J.J. Hardy, Elvis Andrus, Asdrubal Cabrera

Odds

: 20/1

It’s not that Escobar’s season is deserving of so little All-Star consideration as much as the fact that Jeter is pretty much a lock to start the game, while Aviles and Hardy are having terrific seasons for teams having better seasons in higher-profile markets. Don’t discount the notion Washington could reward Andrus with a spot on the team either, while Cabrera – an all-star last year – is playing well again for the division leader.

5. 3B Mike Moustakas Key stats

: .272/.335/.485, 12 2B, 8 HR, 24 RBI, 23 R

Competition

: Mark Trumbo, Miguel Cabrera, Alex Rodriguez, Evan Longoria, Adrian Beltre

Odds

: 30/1

Moose has tapered off a bit in the last 10 days, which has caused his All-Star stock to drop. Of course, there is still time for that to change. But the real problem is the depth at third base in the American League. Trumbo, a second-year player for the Angels who moved to accommodate Albert Pujols’ arrival, is scorching hot for a team that is equally red hot. Meanwhile, Cabrera and A-Rod are grandfathered into the game for the most part.

Then again, they might opt to skip the festivities this season, but with Longoria and another Rangers player in the mix it might be tough for Moustakas to make the field. Still, I’m kind of curious what a Moose chant – Moose call, can we agree on “Moose call?” – would sound like during an All-Star game.

Videos

Join the discussion

is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service