The great U-turn in the U.S. hurts workers and families

03/11/2014 6:13 PM

03/11/2014 6:55 PM

Do you recall a time in America when the income of a single schoolteacher or baker or salesman or mechanic was enough to buy a home, have two cars and raise a family?

I remember. My father (who just celebrated his 100th birthday) earned enough for the rest of us to live comfortably. We weren’t rich but never felt poor, and our standard of living rose steadily through the 1950s and 1960s.

That used to be the norm. For three decades after World War II, America created the largest middle class the world had ever seen. During those years the earnings of the typical American worker doubled, just as the size of the American economy doubled. Over the last 30 years, by contrast, the size of the economy doubled again, but the earnings of the typical American went nowhere.

In that earlier period, more than a third of all workers belonged to a trade union — giving workers the bargaining power necessary to get a large and growing share of the large and growing economic pie.

Then, CEO pay then averaged about 20 times the pay of their typical worker. (Now it’s more than 200 times.)

In those years, the richest 1 percent took home 9 percent to 10 percent of total income. (Today, the top 1 percent gets more than 20 percent.)

Then, the tax rate on highest-income Americans never fell below 70 percent; under Dwight Eisenhower, a Republican, it was 91 percent. (Today, the top tax rate is 39.6 percent.)

In those decades, tax revenues from the wealthy and the growing middle class were used to build the largest infrastructure project in our history, the interstate highway system. And to build the world’s largest and best system of free public education, and dramatically expand public higher education.

We enacted the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act to extend prosperity and participation to African-Americans; Medicare and Medicaid to provide health care to the poor and reduce poverty among America’s seniors; and the Environmental Protection Act to help save our planet.

As the economy grew, we prospered together. And that broad-based prosperity enabled us to invest in our future, creating more and better jobs and a higher standard of living.

Then came the great U-turn, and for the last 30 years we’ve been heading in the opposite direction.


Some blame globalization and the loss of America’s manufacturing core. Others point to new technologies that replaced routine jobs with automated machinery, software and robotics.

But if these were the culprits, why didn’t we share the gains from globalization and technological advances more broadly? Why didn’t we invest them in superb schools, higher skills, a world-class infrastructure?

Others blame Ronald Reagan’s worship of supply-side economics and deregulation. But if these were responsible, why did we cling to these ideas for so long?

Some others believe Americans became greedier and more selfish. But if that’s the explanation, why did our national character change so dramatically?

Perhaps the real problem is we forgot what we once achieved together.

The collective erasure of the memory of broad-based prosperity is due partly to the failure of my generation to retain and pass on values.

We must restore our recollection. We have only to emulate what we once had.

That we once achieved broad-based prosperity means we can achieve it again — not exactly the same way, but in a new way fit for the 21st century and for future generations of Americans.

America’s great U-turn can be reversed. It is worth the fight.


Join the Discussion

The Kansas City Star is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Terms of Service