KansasCity.com

Mobile Site RSS Feeds
Logout | Member Center
Posted on Sat, Jul. 12, 2008 10:15 PM
Buzz UpYahoo Buzz PrintPrint
Comment (0)Comment

READERS’ REPRESENTATIVE

Sometimes, too much of a single viewpoint seems intentional

More News

They call it the “piling-on effect.” A particularly hot news topic gets people talking — and readers perceive that The Kansas City Star gives more space to one side of the argument, stacking the deck of public opinion.

Without question, I’ve heard these complaints most often over the years from political supporters of President Bush. Those objections are frequent and consistent: “The Kansas City Star is nothing but a full-blown organ of the Democratic Party,” said one recent caller. “There’s a radical left-wing agenda in every front-page decision you make.”

Others see just the opposite, especially when accusing The Star of not being critical enough during the run-up to the Iraq war: “A total failure at being the public’s safety valve.”

But moving beyond questions of national politics, I’ve seen even more passionate debate recently about The Star’s coverage of subjects with immediate local impact. The consensus of many readers seems to be that the paper gives the impression of endorsing several ideas that invoke passionate debate: Redevelopment of Kansas City’s downtown, dress codes at the Power & Light District, smoking bans around the metropolitan area, the push for light rail, and criticism of Johnson County District Attorney Phill Kline.

After the Business section’s July 8 story about various dress codes around the area, one reader applauded the story’s “smart nuances,” but asked why The Star has published so many voices knocking the policies, and sometimes even insinuating racist motivations for them:

“You have the editorial, at least two columns, and all the City Council members talking about how terrible this is, but where’s the other side?”

Kline is a frequent focus of comment, as I’ve noted before. It’s certainly true that The Star’s opinion pieces have featured many more knocks than praises for him over the years. And since I work closely with the Letters editor, I can vouch for the fact that traffic there tends to be overwhelmingly negative toward Kline.

A newsroom is a rather decentralized place, and too many individual pieces can appear in different sections over a short period of time, giving the appearance of an orchestrated campaign. Editors may then step in to equalize things — but it’s too late to undo readers’ impressions at that point.

Another strong conservative voice in the roster of staff columnists would also be a powerful safety valve.

Speaking of Kline, a few readers have pointed out radio commercials blasting The Star for not highlighting his positive accomplishments. Some of those criticisms are defensible, but one is an outright lie.

The ad charges that the paper didn’t cover his successful prosecution of John Henry Horton for the 1974 murder of Lizabeth Wilson earlier this year. The four-column centerpiece photo on Page A-1 March 6, in which Kline is smiling and holding the hand of one of Wilson’s brothers, shows that’s simply untrue. In fact, I heard complaints at the time that the picture should have focused on the Wilson family instead.

To reach Derek Donovan, send e-mail to readerrep@kcstar.com or call 816-234-4487 weekdays between 8:30 a.m. and noon. Visit Ad Astrum, the readers’ representative blog, at

Posted on Sat, Jul. 12, 2008 10:15 PM
Buzz UpYahoo Buzz PrintPrint
Comment (0)Comment

Join the discussion

Share your observations and experiences about news. Lively, open, civil debate is the goal. Please refrain from personal attacks or comments that are racist, vulgar or otherwise inappropriate. If you see an inappropriate comment, please click the "Report as abuse" link.

Text alerts Subscribe today!
  1. ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT

    Chapel Hill Presbyterian Church

  2. SERVICE TECHNICIAN

    Superior Door Service, Inc.

  3. LPN'S AND CMT'S

    Garden Valley Nursing & Rehab

  4. Management - Sales

    Confidential Company

View More