Emily Parnell — Adventures in baking: The elusive carrot cake and the forgiving recipe

03/04/2014 5:09 PM

03/04/2014 5:09 PM

“Emily, would you make your famous carrot cake for my birthday?”

Of course, I agreed. I didn’t even know my carrot cake was famous. Who could turn down such flattery? I noted the date, then set about solving a dilemma — the small problem of not knowing what recipe I’ve used before.

Yes, I’ve made carrot cake a couple times before. At one point, I even had a special recipe. A friend gave it to me when I was pregnant, promising that if I made it when I was overdue, I would go into labor while it baked. The carrot cake labor-induction had worked for no less than three people already. I made the cake and did not go into labor. My friend rationalized that I wasn’t overdue enough. But the cake was delicious. Moist, with wonderful texture, aromatic with spices, the recipe was a keeper. Except I didn’t keep it.

By my next hankering for carrot cake, I had lost the special recipe, which I didn’t need anyway since I wasn’t pregnant. I blame the loss on my babies, what with the sleepless nights and diaper fumes. How could I possibly have kept track of a recipe? I searched the net for something that seemed similar. The cake was again phenomenal. And once again, I did not keep it.

So when my famous carrot cake was requested, good ol’ Google provided me yet another recipe.

I can’t say the baking went smoothly. It included approximations, substitutions and one mystery ingredient so mysterious, even today, I can’t tell you for sure what it was.

My very last measuring teaspoon had been mangled in the garbage disposal earlier in the week, so I was operating with a tablespoon. I was concentrating so hard on measuring two teaspoons with the aforementioned tablespoon that I swapped the baking soda and baking powder. Unwilling to start again, I simply scooped out an eyeballed amount, and did my best to measure the other ingredients more carefully.

The real trouble came with the flour. I ran out. Positive there would be more in my cabinet, I rummaged until I found a plastic bag with white powder that looked like flour. It tasted almost like flour — a bit sweeter, slightly salty. Perhaps it was Bisquik? Or coconut flour? Or something else? Regardless, I used it.

The result of this baking adventure proves this recipe is a forgiving one. Not a single piece was left at the end of our birthday party, and my mishaps went unnoticed. This one, I promise, is a keeper.


Join the discussion

is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service