| 1969: Royals 4, Twins 3, 12 inn. |
| 1970: A’s 6, Royals 4 |
| 1971: Twins 2, Royals 0 |
| 1972: Royals 2, White Sox 1, 11 inn. |
| 1973: Royals 12, Rangers 1 |
| 1974: Twins 6, Royals 4, 11 inn. |
| 1975: Royals 8, Twins 3 |
| 1976: Royals 7, Angels 4 |
| 1977: Royals 5, Yankees 4, 13 inn. |
| 1978: Royals 4, Orioles 2 |
| 1979: Royals 11, Blue Jays 2 |
| 1980: Tigers 5, Royals 1 |
| 1981: Tigers 6, Royals 5 |
| 1982: Royals 4, Tigers 2 |
| 1983: Royals 5, Brewers 2 |
| 1984: Royals 4, Yankees 2 |
| 1985: Royals 2, Blue Jays 1 |
| 1986: Blue Jays 6, Royals 2 |
| 1987: White Sox 5, Royals 4 |
| 1988: Blue Jays 5, Royals 3 |
| 1989: Blue Jays 4, Royals 3 |
| 1990: Orioles 7, Royals 6, 11 inn. |
| 1991: Royals 4, Indians 2 |
| 1992: A’s 6, Royals 1 |
| 1993: Red Sox 3, Royals 1 |
| 1994: Indians 8, Royals 3 |
| 1995: Royals 5, Orioles 1 |
| 1996: Royals 5, Red Sox 4, 12 inn. |
| 1997: Royals 6, Orioles 5 |
| 1998: Orioles 11, Royals 7 |
| 1999: Red Sox 5, Royals 3 |
| 2000: Royals 10, Twins 6 |
| 2001: Twins 6, Royals 2 |
| 2002: Twins 8, Royals 6 |
| 2003: Royals 3, White Sox 0 |
| 2004: Royals 9, White Sox 7 |
| 2005: Mariners 8, Royals 2 |
| 2006: Tigers 3, Royals 1 |
| 2007: Royals 7, Red Sox 1 |
| 2008: Royals 5, Yankees 2 |