KansasCity.com

Mobile Site RSS Feeds
Logout | Member Center
Posted on Tue, Nov. 10, 2009 04:31 PM
Buzz UpYahoo Buzz PrintPrint
Comment (0)Comment

Lawyer: No `necessity defense' planned for Roeder

FILE -  In this July 28, 2009 file photo, Scott Roeder attends his preliminary hearing in court in Wichita, Kan. Roeder confessed to the Associated Press Monday, Nov. 9, 2009 to killing abortion provider Dr. George Tiller, saying he has no regrets.
Jaime Oppenheimer, Pool
FILE - In this July 28, 2009 file photo, Scott Roeder attends his preliminary hearing in court in Wichita, Kan. Roeder confessed to the Associated Press Monday, Nov. 9, 2009 to killing abortion provider Dr. George Tiller, saying he has no regrets.
More News

An anti-abortion activist says he's the one who killed a Kansas abortion provider - and did it because it was necessary to save lives. But one of his attorneys says there's no such thing as a "necessity defense" in state law, and that is not the strategy the defense team plans to present at his trial.

Scott Roeder told The Associated Press in a telephone call from jail on Monday that he plans to argue at his trial that he was justified in shooting Dr. George Tiller to protect unborn children.

"We have explored that possibility," public defender Steve Osburn said a day after his client's confession. "That does not seem to be the approach that is viable, nor is it the approach we intend to use."

Roeder, 51, of Kansas City, Mo., is charged with one count of first-degree murder in Tiller's death and two counts of aggravated assault for allegedly threatening two ushers who tried to stop him during the May 31 melee in the foyer of the doctor's Wichita church. Roeder has pleaded not guilty and is scheduled to go to trial in January.

He told the AP he has no regrets about killing Tiller.

His calls to the AP and the Kansas City Star came on the same day several strident abortion opponents released their "Defensive Action Statement 3rd Edition" that proclaims any force that can be used to defend the life of a "born child is legitimate to defend the life of an unborn child."

Osburn said he has discussed with Roeder "on numerous occasions" that a necessity defense was not viable, despite what his client was hearing from others. Roeder has said he is looking for an attorney who will present such a defense but cannot afford to hire one.

His former wife said Tuesday that she was in another room when she heard a television news report play an audio clip of his confession to the AP. Lindsey Roeder said she found it surreal to hear her ex-husband's voice.

"Even though you heard other people say, 'I saw him do it,' even though I have heard since 1993 how he feels about justifiable homicide in response to abortion, it made it all very real," she said. "It was no longer just something we saw on TV or heard in the papers."

Both sides downplayed the impact Roeder's statements to the media would have on their cases.

"It is what it is. He is his own man and we are going to move forward," said Mark Rudy, Roeder's other public defender.

The defense worked out a plan some time ago on how to proceed with the case, and that plan has not changed, Osburn said. He declined to give specifics on the plan.

"I would highly doubt that the state would attempt to call reporters up to the stand to talk about their conversations with Scott, and I say that because they are not going to want to open this up into arguments about things such as justification, when life begins and all those issues," Rudy said.

"I anticipate that they will try to keep this narrow, to the point and try it as a typical murder case," he said. "Therefore they aren't gonna want to open the door to certain other issues that would undoubtedly come out if the media was put up on the stand."

But Rudy left open the possibility that the defense would subpoena the media.

Asked whether his client's public admission makes it harder to defend him, Rudy replied: "It depends on how efficient you are at dodging a subpoena."

Georgia Cole, spokeswoman for the Sedgwick County District Attorney's Office, declined to talk about any specifics of the prosecution's case but said Roeder's confession doesn't have any real effect.

"We will continue to prepare for trial and present our case as in all murder cases," Cole said.

Posted on Tue, Nov. 10, 2009 04:31 PM
Buzz UpYahoo Buzz PrintPrint
Comment (0)Comment

Join the discussion

Share your observations and experiences about news. Lively, open, civil debate is the goal. Please refrain from personal attacks or comments that are racist, vulgar or otherwise inappropriate. If you see an inappropriate comment, please click the "Report as abuse" link.

Text alerts Subscribe today!