- HOME
- NEWS
- SPORTS
- BUSINESS
- FYI/LIVING
- ENTERTAINMENT
- OPINION
- JOBS
- CARS
- REAL ESTATE
- RENTALS
- CLASSIFIEDS
- SHOPPING
- EXTRAS
'); } -->
I almost feel sorry for Rep. Dennis Moore. The Kansas Democrat always seems so torn. He only wants to do the right thing. But deciding what to do is so hard.
On health care, no surprise: He’s landing on the Democratic side, supporting legislation making its way through House committees. But he’s packaging his support with a show of agonizing discomfort and sincere concern, implying that if it were up to him he would handle things more reasonably.
This sort of performance is one reason Moore has held on to his House seat in a predominantly Republican district. Give him credit. He has the routine down pat. He dropped in on The Star’s Editorial Board last week, and what we saw was vintage Moore.
One of the first questions was whether he favored the government-backed “public option,” which would provide health care to “compete” with private insurers (and drive them out of business). The answer: Sort of … No: Maybe.
In a meeting of the Blue Dog Democrats, the moderate Dems who supposedly worry about the budget deficit, Moore was one of only a few to vote in favor of the public option. But that wasn’t his final position. He was just trying to make sure it wasn’t voted down “out of the starting gate.”
Dennis: Do you support the public option or not?
He said he’s not sure what his final position will be. But a Moore staffer distributed a handout saying a public option was one of his goals.
He produced another handout proclaiming that the national debt had reached $11.6 trillion. This is a typical Blue Dog gesture. Moore wants to be seen as concerned about the national debt. But how does one reconcile that concern with a health-care plan the Congressional Budget Office has said will cost more than $1 trillion? How would we ever pay for it?
Moore didn’t know.
“I’m not trying to dodge the question,” he said, “but that is frankly one of the things we need to consider.”
I’ll say.
He suggested the president form a commission to mull the issue.
What about financing health care with higher taxes on the wealthy, as proposed in the House bill?
During a recession, you don’t want to raise taxes, he said. But if something is to be done about health care, raising taxes is “one of the things we should look at.” But he didn’t like the idea. He hoped Congress could find some other way to do it.
He offered no suggestions.
Democrats have been caught flat-footed by the public reaction to their health care plans. That’s hardly surprising. Many people simply don’t trust Congress and the White House.
This debate began as an attempt to deliver health care to the uninsured. But if the House bill passes, virtually everyone will be affected. President Barack Obama has said, “If you like your health care plan, you’ll be able to keep your health care plan, period.”
Not necessarily. There’s no guarantee your health plan would exist. Under the House legislation, the federal government will decide whether your coverage is “acceptable.” The government will determine what benefits are “essential” — a one-size-fits-all federal version of the current mix of cost-boosting state mandates. Insurers will have to bring plans into line within five years.
That means some plans will materially change or cease to exist. The CBO estimates that 3 million people will be dumped from employer-provided health insurance. The Lewin Group offers a much larger estimate: 88 million.
The point is, no one knows what will happen when the bureaucracy begins issuing decrees saying which coverage is “acceptable” and which isn’t.
That’s one reason the poll numbers on health care have flipped. In June, 50 percent backed the legislation in Congress and 45 percent were opposed. In a Rasmussen poll last week, 53 percent were opposed and support had dropped to 42 percent.
It will be fascinating to see how Dennis Moore tap dances his way out of this one.
To reach E. Thomas McClanahan, call 816-234-4480 or send e-mail to mcclanahan@kcstar.com.
@Nyx.CommentBody@