Ball Star

Royals’ Dayton Moore has perfect record (0-0) in arbitration

Updated: 2014-01-13T04:30:38Z


The Kansas City Star

Dayton Moore’s perfect record will be on the line over the next few weeks.

Since being hired as general manager in June 2006, Moore hasn’t lost a single salary arbitration case. He hasn’t won any, either. You guessed it: Not a single Royals player has had a case decided in arbitration under Moore.

On Friday, the Royals signed one of eight players who were arbitration eligible when catcher Brett Hayes agreed to a one-year contract. The other seven arbitration-eligible players are first baseman Eric Hosmer, infielder/outfielder Emilio Bonifacio, outfielder Justin Maxwell and pitchers Greg Holland, Luke Hochevar, Aaron Crow and Tim Collins.

Those seven can file for arbitration on Tuesday, and the Royals and any player would exchange salary proposals by Friday. Hearings are scheduled in February, but the player can sign before — or even during — the hearings.

Yet given Moore’s track record, don’t be surprised if all seven sign before there’s an arbitration hearing. He dismissed any significance with his arbitration history.

“If those particular players were with another club, there probably wouldn’t be a case there either,” Moore said. “I think a lot of it has a lot to do with the situation, the different circumstances surrounding the players. The union and the player have an objective in what they think the player is worth as does the club. The player would never sign unless he felt he was being treated fairly. There’s no pressure on the player’s side.

“If the player is the one who is not satisfied with the deal, he won’t sign. It just depends on who the player is, what the circumstance is ... just the spirit in which the two sides work together to reach a deal. Last year, I don’t believe there was an arbitration deal in Major League Baseball. Every year there might be a handful, but most of them get settled.”

Moore is right. No player’s contract was decided by arbitration in 2013. In fact, in Moore’s tenure, 15 of baseball’s 30 teams (including the entire AL Central) didn’t have a single case decided by an arbitrator, according to

However, in the six years before Moore took over, the Royals had five cases decided by an arbitrator. (The last Royals player to go to arbitration? Outfielder Emil Brown*). So it is noteworthy that Moore hasn’t had a case go to arbitration.

* Insert your own punchline here

Here is a list of the Royals arbitration cases through the years, which comes from and the Kansas City Star archives.

Year Player Player figure Team figure Winner
2006Emil Brown1.775M1.4MPlayer
2005Jeremy Affeldt1.2M950KTeam
2003Carlos Beltran6.95M6MTeam
2002Neifi Perez5M4.1MTeam
2001Greg Zaun1.15M850KPlayer
1999Johnny Damon3.2M2.1MTeam
1997Tom Gordon1.795M1.050MTeam
1994Tom Gordon2.635M1.050MPlayer
Brian McRae1.9M1.3MPlayer
1990Bo Jackson1.9M1.0MTeam
1988Mark Gubicza635K525KPlayer
1987Charlie Liebrandt850K725KPlayer
1986Charlie Liebrandt770K550KPlayer
Bret Saberhagen925K625KPlayer
Steve Balboni525K350KPlayer
1982Willie Mays Aikens375K275KPlayer
Jamie Quirk180K115KTeam
Dan Quisenberry480K300KTeam
1974Cookie Rojas80K67.5KTeam

Deal Saver Subscribe today!


The Kansas City Star is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Kansas City Star uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here