Breaking News

Rules changed in the bidding for Sprint Nextel

Updated: 2013-06-25T15:34:23Z


The Kansas City Star

The bidding for control of Sprint Nextel Corp. lives on but under tougher conditions for upstart bidder Dish Network Corp.

Overland Park-based Sprint has given the satellite television company one week to top a new merger agreement with Tokyo-based SoftBank that was announced late Monday. The revised deal offers $21.6 billion for 78 percent of Sprint and puts new and more expensive hurdles in the satellite television company’s way.

Dish officials haven’t said whether the company plans to boost its bid, only that Sprint has “tremendous” value. Though facing a deadline of next Tuesday, Dish has shown a preference for disruption and some analysts are not counting them out.

SoftBank raised its price after nine months of standing pat on its $20.1 billion deal to buy 70 percent of the nation’s third-largest telecommunications company.

Sprint’s shareholders were set to vote on that offer Wednesday, though the company is expected to adjourn the session without taking action. A “yes” vote would have ended Dish’s chances.

SoftBank calculated its chances and, instead of calling the bet, kicked more money into the pot.

“The deal really was at risk,” said Berge Ayvazian, telecommunications analyst at “They wouldn’t have blinked otherwise.”

Analyst Jennifer Fritzsche at Wells Fargo, in a note to clients, said SoftBank’s revised bid may carry the day. “In our view this move should be enough to get this deal done,” Fritzsche wrote.

SoftBank, however, cut back by $3 billion the amount of cash it will pour into Sprint once the deal closes.

The companies’ battle moves to another venue Thursday. Sprint’s bid to buy the roughly 49 percent of Clearwire Corp. it doesn’t own goes to a vote of the other shareholders. Sprint wants full ownership of its wireless network partner, but Dish may have the top bid there.

Cold cash

Monday’s revised offer from SoftBank comes after the company stood pat following Dish’s $25.5 billion bid for all of Sprint in April.

Analysts had said Dish’s bid, though higher and appealing some large Sprint shareholders, had a debt problem.

“Dish looks like it could be a better deal on the surface,” said Donna Jaegers, an analyst at D. A. Davidson & Co. “But it leaves you with a very indebted company.”

Now that SoftBank has sweetened its payout to Sprint shareholders, a vote to seal the deal is scheduled for June 25.

Sprint shares gained 17 cents Tuesday to close at $7.35.

In an important sweetener for Sprint’s existing owners, shareholders will get more cash for their stock.

Shareholders stand to collect $16.6 billion of the total $21.6 billion price tag under the revised terms. Under the previous offer, they would have received $12 billion.

Cash had been one stumbling block for some Sprint shareholders when comparing SoftBank’s offer with the rival bid Dish made in April. Dish was paying out more cash.

Some unhappy Sprint shareholders had sued to delay Wednesday’s vote, arguing in part that the SoftBank deal was unfair. Johnson County District Judge Thomas Sutherland has put off his decision, given Sprint’s decision to delay the vote itself.

The unhappy shareholders are evaluating the new bid, attorney Steve Six said Tuesday.

Dish hurdles

If Dish remains in the hunt, it faces new obstacles.

Sprint agreed to a bigger break-up fee with SoftBank — $800 million if the deal fails rather than $600 million. In addition, Sprint now may have to to reimburse SoftBank for up to $200 million in fees and expenses, compared with $75 million previously.

Both features essentially make any rival bid that much less valuable to Sprint, forcing a rival bidder — Dish— to pay up.

SoftBank and Sprint also made it tougher for Sprint to find any rival bid “superior” to SoftBank’s new deal.

And Sprint agreed to create a new shareholder rights plan before Dish’s deadline to rebid runs out. This could stop Dish from skipping talks with Sprint and buying shares directly from shareholders.

Dish made just such an offer to Clearwire shareholders. It’s offering $4.40 a share, compared with Sprint’s $3.40 a share.

Kevin Smithen, an analyst at Macquarie Equities Research, said in a note to clients he expects Sprint will raise its Clearwire offer. He said Clearwire likely will delay its vote until June 26, the day after Sprint’s scheduled vote on the SoftBank deal.

Shares of Clearwire gained 8 cents on Wall Street, closing at $4.35.

Higher bid, less money

If there is a loser under the new deal, it is Sprint’s wallet.

SoftBank fattened it last fall with a $3.1 billion down payment shortly after the companies announced the original deal in October. Sprint quickly put the money to work.

It helped fund Sprint’s network upgrade project, it allowed Sprint to work out a deal with a smaller wireless carrier and some of it helped shore up Clearwire’s shaky finances.

SoftBank promised an additional $4.9 billion for Sprint once the deal closed.

Monday’s cash shuffle cuts that by $3 billion. Instead of using that money to bolster Sprint’s finances, SoftBank will be paying it to shareholders.

SoftBank also is adding $1.5 billion more to the deal to further boost the cash that shareholders take home.

In announcing their new deal, Sprint and SoftBank said that the wireless carrier can make do with less. Though still losing money, Sprint’s finances have improved since October, and it has made progress on its network upgrade project.

Nine months of working together also turned up cost and investment savings that the companies said weren’t evident when the first deal was struck. For example, both companies buy cell phones to deliver to subscribers and network equipment. Buying together will allow them to negotiate better prices form the companies that make the equipment.

To reach Mark Davis, call 816-234-4372 or send email to

Deal Saver Subscribe today!


The Kansas City Star is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Kansas City Star uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here