Kansas State University

Klein’s era may be done, but Snyder has more magic

Updated: 2013-01-31T16:02:34Z

By SAM MELLINGER

The Kansas City Star

— Collin Klein is running and when he does it like this, ball tucked high up his arm toward his bicep, he looks about as fast as a part-time security guard. Maybe that’s part of why so many of us underestimated him in the beginning.

But here he goes anyway, like a freight train at top speed. His receivers are all covered. That means most of the defense isn’t looking. These are the moments that gave him that Optimus Klein nickname. He starts running, fast as his legs will carry him, straight for the front corner of the end zone. He knows the cornerback will meet him there for a collision. This is Klein at his best. Switches the ball to his outside arm, and even in a race against the Fastest Team In College Football, Klein can hold his own.

He’s faster than he looks, in that way. Tougher than most anyone who’s tried to tackle him, too, and that means this arm tackle is only ending up on the highlight reel. Klein runs through those arms, of course, and the cornerback tumbles out of bounds, the momentum taking out the referee, too.

It was one of the most Collin Klein plays you can see — Klein doing what Klein do, as the kids say — and it will be a symbol of what we remember about the perfect Kansas State football player.

“He sums up everything we’re about as a team,” Wildcats senior wide receiver Chris Harper says. “He’s probably the toughest dude I’ve ever met.”

It wasn’t enough Thursday night in the Fiesta Bowl, as No. 7 Kansas State lost 35-17 to No. 5 Oregon in the best postseason college football matchup outside Monday’s national championship. Oregon was faster, more explosive, and K-State made too many of the kinds of mistakes they avoided to get here. Other than the touchdown run, Klein had a mostly ineffectual game, and when that happens, K-State is a lesser team.

“We were beaten by a better team,” K-State coach Bill Snyder says. “We just didn’t play that way. We just made too many mistakes.”

The loss was frustratingly reminiscent of the Baylor loss for K-State, an inability to keep up on the scoreboard and a questionable lack of commitment to run forcing a fan base to think more season-long success than one-night disappointment.

Which is part of why K-State fans have reason to worry now.

The Wildcats, 11-2, just finished one of the greatest seasons in school history. This is Snyder’s Manhattan Miracle 2.0, a third Fiesta Bowl for a program once on its way to Division I-AA obscurity. This is one of the greatest coaches in his sport’s history, teaming with an irrepressible quarterback for a run of accomplishment that became respected and cheered even by their rivals.

Together, they created something of a season-long clinic on winning without flash. Their favorite play was the quarterback draw, where Klein pauses for a few moments before running behind his big friends in front of him. They went half a season without a turnover on offense. Didn’t give up a point off a turnover until the 10th game. They beat four ranked teams, scored 50 on two of them, and climbed all the way to the top of the BCS standings before that dud in Waco on a Saturday night.

Klein went to the Heisman Trophy ceremony as a finalist, and Snyder was up for national coach of the year awards. They did so much together, and not just those two but a team driven largely by a senior class that actually came to play for a different coach.

“We had a great opportunity to be part of this team,” K-State senior linebacker Arthur Brown says. “This is not the end. This is the beginning of a new season … our leadership as seniors is not over.”

But their play is, and this is where the worries come.

K-State returns just two starters on defense. Klein is a senior. Same with Harper, the leading receiver. And Olathe East’s Travis Tannahill, the starting tight end.

This is how it often goes in college football, of course, especially at places like K-State that don’t have the depth to turn four-star recruits into backups. New players must step in, always. That’s the cycle of life.

But this will be another enormous task, even for Snyder.

You might remember the last time K-State won a Big 12 title. That was 2003, the year Darren Sproles led the nation in rushing and the Wildcats upset No. 1 Oklahoma in the conference championship at Arrowhead Stadium. That was another glorious year for K-State, which made the fall that much more surprising.

The Wildcats lost seven games the next year, and six more the year after that. Snyder retired, Ron Prince came in, and, with the notable exception of a few games against Texas, things never improved.

For a while, you couldn’t be sure if K-State would have any more seasons like this, the kind that would force people to look at the program from the middle of the country as a national power.

As it turned out, we had to wait almost a decade to see it. Snyder’s next challenge is to prevent a fan base that’s come to believe ubiquitously in his chops from suffering through another gap like that.

He’s whipped bigger challenges than this. One of the best seasons he’s ever coached now over, a region waits to see if he can do it again.

To reach Sam Mellinger, call 816-234-4365, send email to smellinger@kcstar.com or follow twitter.com/mellinger. For previous columns, go to KansasCity.com.

Deal Saver Subscribe today!