COMMENTARY

With Guthrie, Santana in mix, time for Royals to be bold

Updated: 2012-12-02T05:16:27Z

By SAM MELLINGER

The Kansas City Star

One of the most important offseasons in recent Royals history will not, and cannot, end in disaster. That’s what retaining Jeremy Guthrie means, and if this all seems a bit like unintentional comedy — hey, look, we didn’t wreck the car! — well, this is Kansas City.

If the Royals took Offseason 101 as a pass-fail, they at least didn’t fail. If they do nothing else, they will begin 2013 better than they began 2012.

That’s worth something, but simply not drowning is not as good as swimming to safety — and soon enough, the waters will be raging enough that general manager Dayton Moore and the Royals will need safety.

Taking on Ervin Santana’s potential and $12 million salary is a nice step one of a critical offseason with clear needs, and Tuesday’s signing of Jeremy Guthrie to a three-year deal worth $25 million is a nice step two.

But fixing one of baseball’s worst starting rotations is more than a two-step dance. And the third step is the most important.

Completing the project is on owner David Glass as much as it is Moore.


You will hear people say Guthrie is not worth this contract, so let’s get that out of the way here. In the funny-money world of baseball, he is absolutely worth it.

In the last three seasons, while pitching anywhere but Coors Field, Guthrie has a 3.89 ERA.

That’s the same as Max Scherzer, a little better than Ryan Dempster (4.04), and a little worse than — wait for it — Zack Greinke (3.83).

You can argue that the games in Colorado should count, too, but it’s fair to say he’s pitched well everywhere else and besides — including the games at Coors, he’s been better than anybody the Royals have had over that same period.

According to the wonderfully nerdy FanGraphs, Guthrie has been worth $23.8 million over the last three seasons. That includes his awful stretch in Colorado, so when you add in baseball inflation, $25 million over the next three seasons is reasonable.

More important, Guthrie makes the Royals better than they are without him. If nothing else, he and Santana give the team two starters who should be able to pitch 400 innings between them with league average or better performance.

With a bullpen still stocked with power arms, this puts the Royals in a far better position than last year.

This becomes even truer if the team can get good innings from in-house options like Luis Mendoza, Bruce Chen, Everett Teaford, Yordano Ventura, Jake Odorizzi and even Kelvin Herrera.

The heaviest lifting is still to come, though.


The argument that the Royals can’t be fairly expected spend more money can only be made with a straight face and clear conscience if we’re talking about top-of-the-line free agents like Zack Greinke.

With the roster constructed as is, the Royals project to about a $70 million payroll. That’s an improvement over last year, but still comfortably in the bottom quarter of baseball.

Even while the Royals have perhaps the worst TV contract in baseball — their own fault more than market size, by the way — baseball’s revenue sharing is such that they should be able to spend $75 million to $80 million fairly easily.

At that level, any operating loss would be minimal and more than offset by recent profits and the franchise’s value more than tripling from Glass’ purchase price.

This is where general manager and owner must work together, to trust in each other. If Moore has to dip into the team’s wealth of prospects to acquire a frontline pitcher through a trade, then it’s his job to find the right guy. Tommy Hanson, James Shields, Rick Porcello. Someone.

And if Glass has to bump the payroll higher than he’s completely comfortable with, then he should understand that his chances are running out. Fans have been more patient than should be expected through basement payrolls while Glass has steadily said he’d pay more when the time was right.

Well, the time is right. A fan base is burning through its patience.

To reach Sam Mellinger, call 816-234-4365, send email to smellinger@kcstar.com or follow twitter.com/mellinger. For previous columns, go to KansasCity.com.

Deal Saver Subscribe today!